Write the scope before you call anyone
You cannot compare quotes for different work. Write down what is included and what is explicitly excluded, with dimensions, and give the same document to every contractor.
This also tells you a great deal about them. A contractor who reads it, asks three sharp questions and points out something you have missed is a different proposition from one who glances at it and gives you a number.
Finding people
Personal recommendation from someone who has had the same kind of work done, and who you can ask what went wrong as well as what went well. Every job has something that went wrong; the useful question is how it was handled.
Trade association membership and local licensing registers, where they exist. Check what the requirement is in your country rather than accepting a logo — some schemes are meaningful regulation and some are paid directories.
Ask to see two recent jobs of the same type. A good contractor has customers who will take the call.
What to check
Licensing or registration, for the regulated trades. Electrical, gas, plumbing and anything structural are licensed work in most places. Verify it at the source — the register — not from a certificate in a van.
Insurance, current. Public liability at minimum, and employer's liability if they have anyone working for them. Ask for the certificate and check the dates.
Recent, comparable work. Not a portfolio of the best job they ever did. Something like yours, finished within the last year or two.
Who is actually doing the work. The person quoting is frequently not the person on site. Ask who will be there, and whether any of it is subcontracted.
Reading a quote
A quote worth comparing contains:
- The scope, itemised, matching the document you issued
- What is excluded. This is where the differences between quotes live
- Materials: what is included, what is allowed for as a budget figure, and who buys it
- Waste removal — included or not
- Making good: plastering, decorating, the junctions with the rest of the house
- Payment stages
- A start date and an indicative duration
- Whether it is a quote (a fixed price) or an estimate (a figure that can grow). In many countries this distinction carries legal weight
If one quote is dramatically below the others, go through it line by line against the highest one and find the difference. There always is one.
Agree these five things in writing
Not a contract drafted by a lawyer — an email that both of you have.
- Scope, including exclusions
- Price, and whether it is fixed
- Payment stages, tied to completed phases rather than dates, with a retention held until snagging is cleared
- How variations are priced. Agree the mechanism before you need it. "We'll sort it out" is how a budget becomes a negotiation at the worst possible moment
- Practicalities: working hours, access, where materials go, where waste goes, whose electricity and water, what happens to your furniture
During the work
One point of contact, on both sides. Two people in a household giving different instructions to a trade is the most reliable way to get something built wrong.
Decisions in writing, even small ones. A photograph of a chalk mark on a wall with a time stamp settles arguments that memory cannot.
Do not change your mind after first fix unless you are willing to pay for it. The cost of a change rises sharply once walls close.
Keep a running list of things to raise, rather than interrupting daily. Trades work faster when they are not being managed by the hour.
Finishing properly
Walk the job and snag it in daylight, with a written list, before final payment. There is a snagging checklist for this.
Collect the paperwork. Electrical certificate, gas safety record, pressure test results, waterproofing guarantee, building-control sign-off, appliance warranties and manuals. A job without its certificates is not finished, and the documents matter at resale and to your insurer.
Ask for the offcuts and the labels. Spare tile, paint with the colour code, the flooring batch number. Worth very little to the contractor, worth a lot to you in three years.
Then pay the retention promptly once the list is cleared. A contractor who has been treated well is a contractor who answers the phone when something comes loose next winter.
Common questions
- How many quotes should I get?
- Three, against the same written scope. Fewer and you have no basis for comparison; many more and you are wasting good contractors' time, which gets noticed in a local trade.
- What should I check before hiring?
- Licensing or registration for the regulated trades, insurance that is current, and at least two recent jobs you can actually look at or speak to the owner about. What counts as a licence differs by country, so find out what the requirement is where you live rather than accepting a certificate at face value.
- Is a cheap quote a red flag?
- It is a question, not a verdict. Find out what is excluded from it. Usually the gap is waste removal, making good, materials, or an assumption that you have done the preparation. Occasionally it is a contractor who is simply efficient and wants the work.
- What should never be agreed verbally?
- Scope, price, payment stages, how variations are priced, and the start and finish arrangements. Those five in writing prevent almost every serious dispute, and none of them requires a lawyer.
